Assessing the ‘Remaining Segment’ in China’s Fairness Markets


With Zoe Zhang and Richard Knight, Execution Quant Team, CLSA

Zoe Zhang, CLSA

On the institutional brokerage department of CLSA, buying and selling China is a key center of attention for us throughout buying and selling desks. Our crew of quants is all the time on the lookout for tactics to enhance efficiency; a technique we will accomplish that is by means of optimizing execution all the way through the “Remaining Segment”, a definite duration in Chinese language markets which starts on reasonable 40 mins sooner than the remaining bell.

Algorithmic suites wish to dynamically stumble on the start of the Remaining Segment and regulate buying and selling patterns to optimize execution results all the way through this essential duration. At CLSA we do just this. As soon as we now have noticed a trend to the Remaining Segment, we’re prone to examine additional, and all the way through this segment, many stock-specific buying and selling components utilized by CLSA’s ADAPTIVE buying and selling algorithms trade markedly.


In Chinese language fairness markets, skinny public sale volumes on each Shanghai and Shenzhen exchanges pressure buyers who’re concentrated on the with reference to get started executing their order early. This creates an observable microstructure trade and commences the distinct Remaining Segment.

We now have studied numerous microstructure metrics, making an attempt to spot options that display a noticeable and repeatable trade within the run as much as the remaining public sale.

One such metric is order guide replenish time, or the common time taken for the quote measurement to be depleted. The common trade profile for this option is proven within the determine under.

Through the use of the multivariate adaptive regression spline (MARS) modelling method, we will establish the purpose at which this microstructure trade happens — on reasonable, roughly 40 mins sooner than the shut of buying and selling.

There are a selection of China-specific microstructure constraints that lead us to consider this option is a superb proxy for behavioral adjustments comparable to near buying and selling. Those come with regulatory restrictions at the placement-to-cancellation ratio; bizarre lot fills; and conflated marketplace knowledge.

When calculating the full quantity traded inside the Remaining Segment, we discover that this brings mainland markets a lot more in keeping with different advanced markets at round 20% of full-day quantity (when compared with <1% in the true remaining public sale).

You will need to word that whilst Remaining Segment results will also be anticipated to happen at kind of the similar time every buying and selling day, the precise timing will range in line with the volume of members concentrated on the shut, in addition to the liquidity of the inventory.


Our research signifies that the microstructure traits inside the remaining segment are markedly other than the ones seen previous within the buying and selling day.

Richard Knight, CLSA

One notable distinction comes from analysis of the marketplace affect coefficients which can be considerably less than within the pre-close segment.

Some implications for algorithmic buying and selling methods are as follows:

Depending on day by day averages to evaluate microstructure traits is inadequate. Algorithmic suites should be capable of stumble on and adapt to intraday buying and selling levels.

The diminished marketplace affect within the remaining segment will have to be considered when calculating optimum schedules concentrated on Shut, VWAP or IS benchmarks.

Actual-time deviations in key microstructure metrics will also be the most important indication of the volume of buying and selling concentrated on the shut. As such, they may be able to supply distinctive and differentiated options for making improvements to the efficiency of quantity and alpha prediction fashions (see instance of quantity forecast fashion under).

Inside the Remaining Segment, methods can value orders extra passively, maximizing unfold seize with decrease probability of inauspicious variety.


From cautious commentary of microstructure buying and selling metrics, it’s imaginable to spot adjustments in player behaviour that we consider pertains to trades that focus on the shut. Those adjustments outline a Remaining Segment that brings the share of quantity concentrated on the shut a lot more in keeping with different advanced markets. A number of key microstructure options display a noticeable trade all the way through this era; we consider it’s key for execution methods to react to those adjustments in actual time to make sure optimum execution.

At CLSA we acknowledge that the trend in buying and selling China is evolving, and marketplace members wish to adapt. We now have embedded this discovery no longer handiest in our CLOSE Algo to markedly enhance efficiency in opposition to the benchmark, but additionally into our whole ADAPTIVE suite to supply a broader buying and selling edge.

DISCLAIMER: This newsletter is topic to and comprises the phrases and stipulations of use and disclaimers set out on

Leave a Comment